The Tears That Were Only Looking for a Way Out

Crying when you sing is not a breakdown but a release, the body letting go of what it has held. Here is why the voice reaches what words cannot, and how to let the tears come.

TL;DR

•  Crying when you sing or make sound is common, and it is usually not a sign that something is wrong but a sign of release: feeling the body has been holding finally finding a way out.

•  Crying itself appears to be, in part, self-soothing. A review links it to a calming of the body’s stress response and a return to balance, not only to asking others for comfort (Gračanin, Bylsma & Vingerhoets, 2014).

•  Tears to music are physiologically different from the shiver of ‘chills.’ Where chills are arousal, tears appear alongside the body calming itself even as it is moved, a pattern researchers tie to relief and release (Mori & Iwanaga, 2017).

•  Singing does not only express feeling, it helps regulate it. In adults with chronic mental-health conditions, group singing created shared emotional experiences and strengthened emotion regulation (Dingle et al., 2017).

•  Perukua, a vocalist and women’s facilitator whose work has reached women in more than 63 countries, is an artist, not a doctor. She describes the throat as where women “hold a lot of stress,” and sound as how the held emotional body is finally let out.

•  Below: why the voice reaches what words cannot, what the research shows about tears and release, what Perukua says about the emotion stored in the throat, and a gentle practice for letting the tears come when they want to.

The Tears That Arrive the Moment You Open Your Mouth

You are alone in the kitchen, or in the car, or standing in the back row of a choir you joined to get out of the house, and you begin to sing. And before you have finished the first line, before the song has even had the chance to be sad, your throat tightens, your chest fills, and your eyes are brimming, and then you are crying over a tune that is not about anything in particular. You stop. You feel foolish. You look around to see if anyone noticed. You apologise to no one, wipe your face, and quietly decide that there is something wrong with you, that you are too emotional, too fragile, that you had better not do that again. And so the voice goes quiet, and the thing that was trying to move stays stuck.

If this is you, please hear the first and most important thing plainly: you are not broken, and you are not too much. What happened when you opened your mouth and the tears came has a name, and it is not weakness. It is release. The sound reached down into a place where you have been holding something, grief, or fear, or years of swallowed feeling, and it loosened it, and the feeling did what feeling does when it is finally allowed to move: it came up and out. Here is the sentence this piece is built around, worth reading slowly: the tears that come when you sing are not a breakdown, they are a letting go. They are not the problem arriving. They are something old finally leaving.

This matters because of what most of us do with those tears, which is to be ashamed of them and to clamp the voice back down, and in doing so to lose the one thing that was actually helping. So this is a plain account of why the voice reaches down into feeling in a way that talking often cannot, what the research has found about crying and about the particular tears that music draws out of us, what a woman who has spent more than two decades helping women unlock their voices says about the emotion we store in the throat, and a gentle practice for letting the tears come, on purpose and safely, the next time your voice goes looking for them.

What the Research Actually Shows

Begin with crying itself, because so many of us carry the belief that to cry is to fall apart. When researchers reviewed the evidence on what crying actually does, they concluded that it is not only a signal to other people that we need comforting, but very likely a way the body soothes itself from the inside. They describe crying as linked to a calming of the body’s stress response, a settling of the nervous system back toward balance after it has been stirred up (Gračanin, Bylsma & Vingerhoets, 2014). This is a review, drawing together many studies rather than a single experiment, and the authors are careful about it, but the direction is clear and it overturns the old story. The tears are not the emergency. They are, in part, how the body brings itself back down afterward. Which means that when you sing and weep, the weeping is very likely your system doing its own quiet work of coming back to calm.

The second finding is about the specific tears that music pulls out of us, and it is strangely precise. Researchers set out to separate two things we often lump together: the shiver of ‘chills’ down the spine when a song soars, and the welling of tears when a song moves us. They turned out to be physiologically different responses. Chills were a kind of arousal, a quickening. Tears, by contrast, appeared alongside a slowing of the breath even as the heart was stirred, a pattern the researchers described as the body calming itself in the middle of being moved, and associated with a feeling they called pleasurable sadness, a sense of relief and release (Mori & Iwanaga, 2017). The authors propose that this calming reflects the body’s rest-and-restore system coming online, though they did not measure that directly. What they did show is the thing you have felt but perhaps never trusted: that crying to music is not distress, it is catharsis, and that it tends to leave you not more upset but strangely lighter, clearer, more yourself.

The third finding moves from listening to actually making the sound, which is where the tears so often come. In a study of adults living with chronic mental-health conditions, researchers found that singing in a group did more than lift the mood for an afternoon: it created shared emotional experiences and strengthened the participants’ ability to regulate their feelings, to let emotion rise and move through them rather than staying jammed (Dingle, Williams, Jetten & Welch, 2017). This is the piece that connects the others. Singing is not only a way to express a feeling you already know you have. It is a way to process one, to let the body do with sound what it could not do with thought. The tears, in that light, are not an interruption of the singing. They are the singing working.

What Perukua Says About the Emotion in the Throat

Perukua, a vocalist and women’s facilitator whose practice-based work has reached women in more than 63 countries over more than two decades, is an artist and a facilitator, not a doctor or a therapist, and nothing she offers is a treatment for trauma or any condition. But helping women unlock a voice that has gone tight or silent is the centre of her life’s work, and she begins exactly where the tears begin, which is the throat. “We hold a lot of stress in the throat,” she says, “and we have never been taught to breathe like ah.” In her practice the open, falling sound on the out-breath is not a singing exercise but a kind of key: “ahhh,” she says, “is a releasing primal breath.” The throat, in her account, is where so many women have quietly stored what they could not say, the swallowed no, the unwept grief, the feeling held in so long it set like a collar, and sound is what loosens it.

She is direct, too, about what this can look like, because she has watched it happen in rooms full of women for years, and she does not want anyone frightened by it. The first time a woman really lets her voice vibrate and open, Perukua reports, the feeling that comes can be strong and can surprise her. “Sometimes you can cry,” she says, “because you just feel so much suppression coming out of you, or sometimes anger that you have experienced.” And she names it, plainly, as a good thing: “it can be a big, big, big release.” The stuck feeling, in her telling, is not fragile and dangerous but something that “wants to come out and wants to shake out of you,” and when it finally does, “that is a very beautiful thing.” The tears are not the voice failing. They are the voice doing precisely what it is for.

Underneath all of it is her simplest claim about why the voice, and not only talking, is what moves the held feeling. “We need our voice to release the emotional body,” she says, describing the way a woman who has spent all day in her thinking mind, managing, planning, holding everything together, loses touch with what she actually feels until it has nowhere to go (translated from Russian). The mind, in her view, is where we hold the feeling down; the voice is how we let it up. This is why she calls the voice, in the moment it opens, the one that will “play the master role of the healer,” a vibration that “unblocks your body and shakes your body.” You do not cry because the singing hurt you. You cry because the singing reached what the talking never could.

Why the Voice Reaches What Words Cannot

Most of us, when we are carrying something heavy, are told to talk about it, and talking can help a great deal. But many women discover, often after years of it, that there is a layer the talking never quite touches, a weight that stays in the body no matter how clearly they have explained it to themselves or to a kind professional across a room. This is not a failure of therapy, and it is not a sign the talking was wasted. It is that some of what we hold was never stored as words in the first place. It was stored as tension, as a held breath, as a closed throat, and you cannot reliably reason your way into a place that does not speak the language of reason. The body kept the feeling, and the body is where it has to be let go.

Sound reaches that layer because it does not go through the thinking mind at all. You cannot strategise and truly sing at the same time; the moment the voice opens and the breath drops low, the managing part of you has to step back, and the gate it was holding shut, that tightness in the throat you may know as the lump that comes just before tears, is suddenly no longer being held. The sound passes through it, and what was waiting behind it comes with it. This is why the tears so often arrive not after long reflection but in the first few seconds, before you have had time to decide anything. The voice got there first. It found the held thing before your mind could tighten the collar again.

A word of care and honesty here, because the phrase people often reach for is ‘trauma release,’ and it is worth being precise. Not every tear that comes with a song is the surfacing of some deep buried wound. Very often it is simpler and no less real: the ordinary accumulated grief of a life, the tiredness, the things you never had time to feel because you were busy holding everyone else. That is release too, and it is enough reason to let the sound keep moving. And sometimes, for some women, what rises is bigger, older, and more tender, and that deserves not to be handled alone with a playlist but gently, and often with a trauma-informed professional alongside the singing. Either way, the principle Perukua describes and the research supports holds: the voice is one of the oldest ways a human body has of letting go of what it has been carrying. The tears are the carrying, finally, being set down.

A Practice: Letting the Tears Come When They Want To

This is not a practice for forcing tears, which cannot be done and should not be tried. It is a practice for making it safe for the voice to open, so that if something is waiting to move, it is allowed to, without shame and without alarm. It takes about ten minutes, it asks nothing of your singing ability, and it is best done alone, where no one can hear you and you do not have to be anything for anyone. It is adapted from the way Perukua guides women to unlock the throat.

First, make it private, and give yourself permission. Find a place where you will not be overheard, the car, a closed room, a walk on an empty path. This matters more than it sounds, because part of what keeps the voice shut is the lifelong sense of being listened to and judged. Say to yourself, out loud if you can, something like: no one is here, nothing has to sound good, and whatever comes is allowed. You are not performing. You are opening a door and standing back.

Second, breathe low and soften the throat. Rest one hand on the base of your throat and one on your chest. Breathe in slowly through the nose, letting the breath drop as low as it will go, and then let it out through an open mouth on a long, falling “haaa,” the sound Perukua calls the releasing primal breath, as if you were fogging a mirror with your whole chest. Do this five or six times. Do not push the sound; let it be more sigh than song. Feel the throat, under your hand, begin to loosen the collar it has been holding.

Third, let a simple sound carry whatever rises. Now let the out-breath find a single easy note, any note, low and comfortable, and hold it gently, a long open ahhh or a soft hum, feeling it vibrate in your chest and throat under your hands. Let one note become a few. You are not trying to make a melody. You are giving the held feeling a current to travel on. If your throat tightens, if your eyes sting, if the tears come, this is the practice working, not failing. Keep the sound going, softly, even as you cry. Do not swallow it back down. Let the sound and the tears move together, which is exactly what they were waiting to do.

Finally, let it close, and be kind to what moved. When the sound wants to grow quiet, let it. Sit for a minute with your hands still resting on your chest and throat, and breathe slowly, and notice how you feel, which is often lighter, emptied in a good way, a little tender. You might whisper a word of thanks to yourself for letting it come. If what rose was very big, overwhelming, or frightening, or if it brought back something you have carried alone for a long time, please treat that as the signal it is and bring it to a doctor or a trauma-informed therapist, who can walk beside you. The voice opens the door. For some rooms, you deserve company going in.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Why do I cry when I sing?

Because singing reaches feeling that your thinking mind has been holding down, and lets it move. When you sing, the breath drops low and the throat opens, and the tension you may know as the lump in your throat is no longer being held shut, so whatever was waiting behind it can come up and out. Crying itself is very likely a way the body soothes and rebalances itself, not a sign of falling apart (Gračanin, Bylsma & Vingerhoets, 2014), and tears drawn out by music tend to come with a feeling of relief rather than distress (Mori & Iwanaga, 2017). In short, the tears are release, not a malfunction.

Is crying when I sing a sign of trauma being released?

Sometimes, but not always, and it is worth being honest about the difference. Often the tears are simpler and no less real: the ordinary accumulated grief, tiredness, and swallowed feeling of a full life, finally finding a way out through the voice. That is genuine release and a good reason to let the sound keep moving. Occasionally, for some people, singing stirs something older and more tender, and when that happens the wisest thing is not to work through it alone but to let a trauma-informed therapist walk beside you. The voice is a powerful way to let go of what the body holds, but deep trauma deserves skilled, gentle company, not a playlist alone.

Is it embarrassing or a bad thing to cry while singing?

No. It is one of the most natural things a voice can do, and far more common than the silence around it suggests. The shame most of us feel is learned, the long habit of being watched and judged, not a verdict on the tears themselves. Research on singing in groups found it created shared emotional experiences and helped people manage their feelings rather than harming them (Dingle et al., 2017). If the tears embarrass you, the kindest fix is privacy, not suppression: sing somewhere no one can hear, so you can let the voice and the feeling move freely without an audience to perform for.

Can singing really help release stored emotions and grief?

It can be a real and gentle support. Making sound engages the body and the breath directly, reaching feeling that talking does not always touch, which is why so many people find that singing lets emotion rise and pass through instead of staying stuck. Studies suggest singing supports emotion regulation and shared emotional release (Dingle et al., 2017), and that crying to music tends toward relief and calm (Mori & Iwanaga, 2017). It is a gentle complement to proper care, not a replacement for it. For heavy grief or trauma, singing can sit alongside the support of a doctor or therapist, never instead of it.

Go Deeper with Perukua

If the tears that come when you sing tell you there is something your voice has been carrying, Perukua’s Vocal Yoga is a gentle place to begin. Built on her Root-to-Throat method, it guides you, at your own pace and in your own home, to breathe low, open the throat, and let your voice move again, exactly the slow, safe unlocking this piece describes. It asks no singing ability and no audience, only a little privacy and willingness. It is not therapy or medical care, and it is not a treatment for trauma, grief, or any condition; if what rises when you sing is overwhelming, that belongs with a doctor or a trauma-informed therapist. But as a way to let the voice do its oldest work, the quiet letting go of what you have held, it is the practice version of everything written here.

In Closing

So the next time you open your mouth to sing and, from nowhere, the tears come, you might try meeting them differently. Not with the old embarrassment, the quick apology, the clamping shut of the one thing that was helping. And not with the old verdict about yourself either, that you are too emotional, too fragile, too much, because that verdict is both untrue and part of what kept the feeling locked in your throat for so long. The tears are not a breakdown. They are something you have carried, for a day or for decades, finally being allowed to move, on the breath, through the voice, and out. Let them come. Keep the sound going, softly, even as you cry. They were never a sign that something is wrong with you. They were only looking for a way out, and your voice, at last, showed them the door.

This piece is general reflection on wellbeing, not medical or psychological advice, and Perukua is an artist and facilitator, not a doctor or therapist. Breath and sound practices are a gentle support for emotional release and a settled nervous system, not a treatment for trauma, grief, depression, or any medical or psychological condition, and the descriptions attributed to her are her own way of speaking about her craft, not clinical claims. If singing consistently brings up overwhelming grief, flashbacks, panic, or distress, or if you are carrying trauma, please treat that as the important thing it is and reach out to a doctor or a qualified, trauma-informed therapist, who can walk beside you. The voice opens the door; for some rooms, you deserve skilled company going in.

References & Quote Sources

1.

Gračanin, A., Bylsma, L. M., & Vingerhoets, A. J. J. M. (2014). Is crying a self-soothing behavior? Frontiers in Psychology, 5, 502. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00502

2.

Mori, K., & Iwanaga, M. (2017). Two types of peak emotional responses to music: The psychophysiology of chills and tears. Scientific Reports, 7, 46063. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep46063

3.

Dingle, G. A., Williams, E., Jetten, J., & Welch, J. (2017). Choir singing and creative writing enhance emotion regulation in adults with chronic mental health conditions. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56(4), 443–457. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjc.12149

Do you have any questions? Contact me now

Should you have any questions, please contact me via messengers below. I'll reply you shortly.